Perhaps one of the most widely read anthropological essays, “Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight” by Clifford Geertz is available. Shortly after the election, I taught “Notes on a Balinese Cockfight” to my Anthropological Theory class, as I always do, at that point in the. “Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight” is one of Clifford Geertz’s most influential articles which illustrates not only the meaning of a given.
|Published (Last):||5 May 2006|
|PDF File Size:||16.95 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||20.13 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Material as opposed to what? In The Interpretation of Cultures Geertz explicitly contrasts his position that symbols are found in public behavior with public meanings to psychological approaches that equate culture with mental models Ward Goodenough or subconscious emotions Culture and Personality studies influenced by Freudthus making culture invisible or a theoretical artifact created by the observer. That makes a lot more sense, and, in my case, explains why, when I went looking for how to produce a thick description, I turned to Victor Turner.
Rola brings up an interesting point. To ask of any cultural text, be it a cockfight or a folktale, who is talking, who is being talked to, what is being talked about, and what form of action is being called for, is to move cultural analysis to a new level that renders the old antinomies of materialism and idealism irrelevant. Despite being illegal, cockfighting is a widespread and highly popular phenomenon in Bali, at least at the time “Deep Play: However the fight, according to Geertz, is not between individuals but is rather a simulation of the social structure of kinship and social groups.
To start form the bottom line, Clifford Geertz ‘s essential notion expressed in ” Deep Play: I think that the word statues must be replaced with status in the 4th paragraph. With bets fairly even in the case of a deep fights, financial gain is not the center of the event, but coockfight everything which is expressed in the concept of “status”. Like a lot of people I read the Balinese cockfight article in my anthropological youth and I remember enjoying it although the Person, Time, balunese Conduct essay in that same volume was the one that really captured my attention.
On the established anthropological principle, When in Rome, my wife and I decided, only slightly less instantaneously than everyone else, that the thing to do was run too. For example, women and young and socially disadvantaged people are not allowed to attend cockfights, while the main players are the most respected and politically involved members of the community.
If the narrative of this election were written as a short story, with actual events and quotes worked into the plot, an English class somewhere would analyze it cofkfight a feminist commentary — where the sexism of mainstream society is made visible through ongoing instances of explicit phallocentrism. Notes on the Balinese Cockfight. The last half of the essay describes the rituals of betting and concludes that the cockfight is the Balinese comment on themselves, as it embodies the network of social relationships in kin and village that govern traditional Balinese life.
Has an Indonesian scholar written a reaction to the piece? The man could not have been more appropriately named cockgight we were in a medieval morality play and at times it felt like we were.
The Balinese cockfight is, as Geertz puts it, a way of playing with fire without getting burned. Cockfights are illegal and the sudden appearance of the police during one of the first fights Geertz and his wife witnessed sent everyone scurrying home: Accessed December 31, He persuades me that thick description is better than cockfihgt thin explanations that anthropologist typically provide but offers no criteria for deciding when one description is better than another.
To learn that Balinese lose themselves in cockfights, which are, ballinese least from one perspective, exemplars of selves they want to be, victors in short, bloody, violent conflicts that elevate status may contribute to our understanding of why Bali, now normally seen as a beautiful tourist trap inhabited by lovely people with an extraordinary level of self-control, was, shortly after WWII, the scene of fockfight that killed I need to check the numbers around 80, people.
Self-mockery seems to be an essential ingredient for making an anthropological classic. His discussion of the role of sexual [gender?
Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight by Clifford Geertz
This page was last edited on 26 Januaryat I suppose Geertz would admit that the interpretive process is heavily determined by all sort of outside factors, but he rarely makes this a factor in his writing. Considered Geertz’s most seminal work, the essay addresses the meaning of cockfighting in Balinese culture. Ba,inese, the Supreme Court defense of same-gendered unions? Just like in the West, the cock in Bali symbolizes masculinity, and the rules of cockfights in every village are passed down through generations along with other legal traditions.
We may have moved away from the type of culturalism that ignores the political and economic context, but it seems pretty banal to point this out, at least in American anthropology French anthropology being another story.
Much as I respect oneman, this is just plain wrong.
“Notes on a Balinese Cockfight” and Donald Trump | Somatosphere
It is a society’s manner of speaking to itself about itself, and is therefore of prime interest for the anthropologist.
She co-edits the journal Laboratorium: It channels aggression and rivalry into an indirect symbolic sphere of engagement. The only place power comes into play in this formulation is in who has access to particular symbols.
Except this is not a short story.
Intellectuals have an interesting critical relationship with archetypes, especially when they appear as instances of synecdoche — they are such concentrated semiotic clusters that when they are intentionally deployed in coclfight, we are balniese to read them as allegory.
Cockfights are illegal and the sudden appearance of the police during one of the first fights Geertz and his wife witnessed sent everyone scurrying home:. We ran down the main village street, northward, away from where we were living, for we were on that side of the ring.
How does the Balinese cockfight, in conversation with the effectiveness of symbols, relate to, explain, or otherwise incorporate the popularity and role of Michelle Obama in the Obama presidency? The cockfights are illegal but widespread, with cocks — roosters — serving as proxies for powerful men and their status competition. In Taiwan, when Ruth and I were doing fieldwork inthe first thing we did when arriving in Puli was report to the foreign affairs policeman who seemed, in fact, a very pleasant person…but anyway.
Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. This is what actually happened in this election.
Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight by Clifford Geertz
More Geertz online at HyperGeertz. The fights both represent and take part in forming the social and cultural structure of the Balinese people which are dramatized through the cockfight. Based on a large pool of observations and interviews, Coockfight concludes that the cockfight as a cultural phenomenon offers rich anthropological material for the interpretation of the Balinese society. Geertz shows how the Balinese cockfight serves as a cultural text which embodies, at least a portion of, what the real meaning of balinesf Balinese is.
ANd, of course the fact that we can still develop a pretty hearty discussion suggests that the issues raised by Geertz around cockfiyht time I was born are still far from totally settled.